A comprehensive guide to mastering relay coordination, ensuring system selectivity, preventing blackouts, and adhering to global IEEE/IEC safety standards.
A comprehensive guide to mastering relay coordination, ensuring system selectivity, preventing blackouts, and adhering to global IEEE/IEC safety standards.
A Protection Coordination Study is a systematic engineering analysis used to determine the optimal settings for power system protective devices, such as relays, fuses, and circuit breakers. The primary goal is to ensure that when a fault occurs (such as a short circuit), the device closest to the fault trips first, isolating the minimum amount of equipment necessary while keeping the rest of the system operational.
Selectivity, often referred to as discrimination, is the ability of the protection system to distinguish between a fault in its own zone and a fault in a neighboring zone. Correct coordination ensures that a downstream breaker clears a local fault before the upstream main breaker trips. Without this, a minor fault on a sub-feeder could cause a total facility blackout.
Beyond operational continuity, coordination studies are a safety mandate. Improperly coordinated devices can lead to prolonged fault clearance times, significantly increasing the incident energy during an arc flash event. Regulatory bodies like OSHA and standards like NFPA 70E require updated studies to ensure personnel safety and equipment longevity.
Time grading involves setting time delays on upstream relays to allow downstream devices to clear a fault first. The “Coordination Time Interval” (CTI)—typically 0.2 to 0.4 seconds—is added to the backup relay’s operating time to account for breaker opening time, relay overshoot, and safety margins.
Current grading utilizes the difference in fault current magnitude at different points in the network. Since impedance increases as you move away from the source, fault currents are lower at the end of the line. Relays can be set to trip instantaneously for high-current close-in faults while delaying for lower-current remote faults.
Most overcurrent relays operate on an “Inverse Time” basis, meaning the higher the fault current, the faster the relay trips. These characteristics are visualized on Time-Current Curves (TCC). Understanding the slope of these curves (Standard, Very, or Extremely Inverse) is vital for coordinating fuses with relays.
The foundation of any study is accurate data. Engineers must gather utility fault data, transformer impedances, cable sizes/lengths, and motor contribution data. This information is used to build a precise One-Line Diagram (SLD) that mathematically models the entire electrical network.
Before settings can be determined, you must know the minimum and maximum fault currents at every bus. A Short Circuit Study calculates the symmetrical and asymmetrical fault currents (3-phase, Line-to-Ground) to ensure all equipment is rated to withstand the available energy.
Step 3: Determining Pickup and Time Dial Settings
Engineers calculate the Pickup (Tap) setting to ensure the relay ignores normal load currents but detects minimum fault currents. The Time Dial (TDS or TMS) is then adjusted to position the relay curve vertically, establishing the necessary time delay for coordination with downstream devices.
Step 4: Plotting Time-Current Curves (TCC)
Using the calculated data, engineers plot TCCs on a log-log graph. This visual representation displays the tripping characteristics of fuses, breakers, and relays on a single page, allowing engineers to visually verify that the downstream curves (left/bottom) do not overlap with upstream curves (right/top).
Step 5: Verifying Sequence of Operation and Clearing Times
The final step is validation. The sequence of operation is simulated to ensure that for any given fault location, the devices operate in the correct order. Clearing times are also checked against equipment damage curves (such as ANSI transformer damage points) to ensure the equipment survives the fault.
This standard defines the mathematical equations for the curves used in microprocessor-based relays. It standardizes curve types like “Moderately Inverse,” “Very Inverse,” and “Extremely Inverse,” ensuring that a relay from Manufacturer A can coordinate with a relay from Manufacturer B.
IEC 60255 governs the design and performance of measuring relays and protection equipment globally. Concurrently, NFPA 70E (Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace) relies on accurate coordination studies to calculate Arc Flash boundaries and determine the PPE required for workers.
The National Electrical Code (NEC) Articles 240 and 450 mandate specific protection requirements for conductors and transformers. A valid coordination study must respect these limits, ensuring that settings do not exceed the maximum allowable ampacity or thermal limits of the system components.
ETAP is a widely used industry standard for power system analysis. Its “Star Protection & Coordination” module offers automated protection logic, sequence-of-operation verification, and an extensive library of device models from virtually every manufacturer.
SKM is renowned for its “Captor” TCC interface. It is highly favored in the U.S. industrial sector for its robust integration with Arc Flash studies. It allows for easy drag-and-drop curve adjustments and comprehensive reporting for compliance audits.
Popular in Europe and for transmission-level studies, PowerFactory handles highly complex networks, including those with significant renewable energy integration. Unlike ETAP/SKM which focus on industrial radial systems, PowerFactory excels in meshed network coordination.
Curve overlap often occurs when coordinating a fast-acting fuse with an upstream relay. To resolve this, engineers may switch the relay curve type (e.g., from Very Inverse to Standard Inverse) or tighten the Coordination Time Interval (CTI) if digital relays are used, as they eliminate mechanical overshoot.
Mixing vintage electromechanical disk relays with modern microprocessor relays is difficult because old relays have significant “coast” or momentum after the current stops. Coordination studies must add extra time margins (typically 0.1s extra) to account for this mechanical lag.
The addition of solar or wind power introduces bidirectional fault currents. Standard coordination assumes power flows from utility to load. DG can “blind” relays or cause “sympathetic tripping,” requiring advanced directional overcurrent elements (ANSI 67) rather than standard overcurrent (ANSI 50/51).
Proper relay coordination is the backbone of https://aurasafety.com/a safe and reliable electrical power system. By strictly adhering to procedures like data validation, short circuit analysis, and TCC plotting, facility managers can prevent nuisance tripping and catastrophic equipment damage.
Aura Safety Risk Consultant
Delivering comprehensive HSE management and engineering consultancy solutions to ensure safety, compliance, and sustainable industrial growth.
Contact Us Today:
Phone: +91 9999 402 106
Website: aurasafety.com/contact-us
+91 99994 02106
Identifies arc flash hazards and defines safe working limits
Evaluates electrical risks to prevent failures and accidents
Analyzes power quality issues caused by electrical harmonics
Classifies hazardous zones for safe electrical equipment use
Assesses lightning threats and protection system needs
Electrical safety audits and engineering solutions minimizing risks, preventing accidents.
Calculates fault currents to ensure system safety
Detects overheating in electrical equipment using infrared
According to NFPA 70B and industry best practices, a study should be updated every 3 to 5 years, or immediately whenever there is a significant change in the system (e.g., adding large motors, changing transformers, or utility grid changes).
Protection focuses on detecting a fault and tripping a breaker to prevent damage. Coordination focuses on which breaker trips and when. Protection ensures safety; coordination ensures reliability and selectivity.
Essential data includes the Utility Short Circuit Contribution (MVA/X/R ratio), Single Line Diagram (SLD), transformer nameplate data (kVA, Impedance %Z), cable schedules (size, length, type), and existing protective device settings.
ANSI 50 denotes Instantaneous Overcurrent, and ANSI 51 denotes Time-Delay Overcurrent protection.
CTI is the minimum time gap (usually 0.2 s - 0.4 s) required between the operation of primary and backup devices to ensure selectivity
Faster coordination settings reduce the duration of a fault, which directly lowers the incident energy and Arc Flash hazard category.
Phase coordination protects against line-to-line/3-phase faults, while Ground coordination specifically targets line-to-ground faults, often requiring much lower pickup settings.
Unlike Inverse curves, Definite Time relays trip after a fixed time delay, regardless of how high the fault current is.
Transformers have a "frequent" and "infrequent" mechanical damage limit. Relays must trip before the fault current crosses these damage curves to prevent catastrophic failure
No, fuses have fixed TCCs. Coordination is achieved by selecting the correct fuse class and ampere rating relative to upstream/downstream devices.
